Negligent Inheritance Tax Advice and the APR/BPR Reform

Yes, you may be able to claim against the solicitor, accountant or financial planner who advised you, if their inheritance tax planning left your family with a larger bill after the 6 April 2026 reforms to agricultural property relief (APR) and business property relief (BPR) than competent advice would have produced. The qualification is timing: the reforms were announced and then changed more than once, so the question is what a careful adviser would have told you on the day you were advised, and the limitation clock may already be running.

The people who ask us about this are mostly farming and family-business households, executors who have opened the tax calculation and found a figure the family never expected, and beneficiaries who were told the farm or the company would pass down free of tax. Most assume that because Parliament changed the law, nobody can be blamed. That is only partly right, and the exceptions usually turn on dated emails and file notes from the period between 30 October 2024 and April 2026. If you are weighing up claims against negligent tax advisers, the dates matter more than the headline numbers.

Want legal advice on the merits of your case?

Your legal enquiry goes immediately to our PN litigation team in Middle Temple, London. We can’t take on low value cases or give free legal advice – our minimum fee is £1750 +VAT for a conference with a solicitor and barrister. Call us on +442071830529.

What changed on 6 April 2026

Before that date, relief at 100% on most qualifying agricultural and business property had no cash limit. The reform caps it. Under section 124D(2) of the Inheritance Tax Act 1984 (IHTA 1984), as inserted by Finance Act 2026, the 100% relief allowance is £2.5 million less the amount by which earlier transfers in the previous seven years were reduced by 100% relief, and section 124D(3) defines that period as the seven years ending with the day of the transfer. Value above the allowance is treated as “reduced by 50%” under sections 104(1) and 116(1). The Autumn Budget 2024 proposed a £1 million allowance, and on 23 December 2025 the government raised it to £2.5 million. Disputes with HMRC about how these reliefs apply fall under tax litigation, which is a different matter from the claim against an adviser discussed below.

Several other features matter to families. An unused allowance can pass to a surviving spouse or civil partner, but section 124E(5) applies only “where a claim is made under this section”, so someone has to make it, and government guidance says the transfer is available even if the first death was before 6 April 2026. Gifts made on or after 30 October 2024 are caught if the donor dies on or after 6 April 2026 within seven years, and trusts have a separate £2.5 million allowance. Tax on qualifying property can be paid in ten equal yearly instalments if the person paying elects in writing under section 227(1), and the government has extended that option to all APR and BPR property. Executors who find that one of these steps was missed can read about our work advising executors and personal representatives on probate.

A worked example of the extra tax

Take a farmer who dies owning £4 million of qualifying farmland and business assets, with no gifts in the previous seven years and no spouse to inherit. The first £2.5 million attracts 100% relief. The remaining £1.5 million attracts 50% relief, leaving £750,000 chargeable, which at 40% is £300,000 of tax before any nil-rate band. That is an effective rate of 20% on the excess, which matches the government’s own description of the reform. The figures are our own illustration, and a real estate will have other assets, earlier gifts and other reliefs, while the residence nil-rate band tapers away for estates over £2 million. Our guide to how compensation is calculated in a professional negligence claim shows how a court turns a tax figure into damages.

The £300,000 does not on its own show a loss. A claim measures the difference between where you are and where you would have been with competent advice, so if no available step would have reduced the tax, the adviser’s failure may have cost you nothing. If a timely gift, a different structure or a claim under section 124E would have saved tax, that saving is the starting point for damages, together with the cost of putting matters right. An adviser answers only for losses within the scope of the work they undertook, and recoverable damages in professional negligence claims explains where the line falls.

Was the advice negligent, or simply overtaken by the law?

An adviser is judged by what a competent practitioner would have advised at the time, without hindsight. Advice given before the Autumn Budget on 30 October 2024 that assumed the old rules is unlikely to be negligent merely because the rules later changed. Advice given afterwards stands differently, because the reform had been announced and a competent adviser acting for a farming or business family would ordinarily be expected to raise it. Our guide to breach of duty in professional negligence explains how the standard is applied, and the date of each piece of advice decides which side of the line it falls.

The allowance was proposed at £1 million and became £2.5 million on 23 December 2025, and the transfer of unused allowance between spouses was announced in the Autumn Budget 2025. An adviser who planned, before that transfer was announced, on the footing that a first spouse’s allowance would be lost unless used on that death was working from the announced rules. The same advice given afterwards deserves closer scrutiny. Our page on negligent tax scheme advice claims shows how these questions are framed.

Wills that waste or fail to use the allowances

A will can be where the loss happens. Leaving everything to a surviving spouse is generally exempt under section 18(1) IHTA 1984, because the value passes to the transferor’s spouse or civil partner, so no relief is needed on that death and the unused allowance is what can pass to the survivor. If nobody makes the claim under section 124E, the survivor’s estate may have only a single allowance where it could have had more. Our page on negligent will writing and defective wills explains that a will which wastes an inheritance tax exemption or relief leaves the executors paying tax that careful drafting would have avoided.

Not every drafting choice is a mistake. A solicitor may follow clear instructions, and many wills made before the reform were sensible when signed. The questions are whether the solicitor asked about business and farming assets and explained the tax consequences of the structure chosen. If the retainer was continuing, a further question is whether anything was said once the changes were announced. Where the file shows nothing, legal negligence claims against solicitors and barristers may be open to you.

Accountants, financial planners and solicitors: who owes you what

Each adviser owes a duty of care within the work they agreed to do. An accountant who valued your business and prepared your tax computations may owe you a duty to warn about tax consequences they could see, and our page on an accountant who failed to warn about a tax liability covers that claim. A financial planner who recommended gifts, trusts or investments to obtain relief owes a duty set by the advice given, and our guide to negligence claims against financial advisers deals with losses and time limits.

Where several advisers worked on one plan, the paperwork decides who is responsible for what. Engagement letters set the scope, and a letter limited to a will or to tax returns can narrow what you recover. Some letters also cap liability, and our page on limitation of liability clauses covers whether you can still sue your adviser.

Beneficiaries and executors who never hired the adviser

Many of the people who suffer the loss were never the adviser’s client. A son who inherits the farm, or a daughter who has to find the tax, may be able to claim where the adviser took on work intended to benefit them and the loss fell on them. The principle that a duty can be owed to an intended beneficiary is established, and our pages on whether a third party can sue a professional for negligent advice and on solicitors’ duty of care to third parties explain when it applies.

Executors stand differently. They can pursue claims that the person who died had against an adviser, and because they pay the tax they are often the first to see the problem. A claim by the estate and a claim by a beneficiary cannot both recover the same loss, so who sues, and for what, needs deciding early. Our page on probate solicitor errors and delays covers claims by executors and beneficiaries against the solicitor administering the estate.

Why searches for an inheritance tax claim often lead to the wrong help

People searching for a claim after a large inheritance tax bill often find material about challenging the tax itself. A dispute with HMRC asks whether the tax was correctly charged, for example whether HMRC valued an asset properly or was right to refuse relief. A negligence claim asks whether your adviser’s failure made you pay tax you would otherwise have avoided. Our page on HMRC inheritance tax disputes covers the first situation, including how an estate is valued, and our page on HMRC tax investigations covers enquiries into returns.

The two can overlap. If HMRC challenges the relief claimed, the executors may have to defend that position and keep the adviser on notice at the same time. Resolving the HMRC dispute first does not stop time running against the adviser, and any penalty HMRC charges may form part of the loss, which our page on HMRC penalties covers.

Practical steps for executors and families in the first weeks

Tax on a death is due six months after the end of the month of death under section 226(1) IHTA 1984, and personal representatives pay the tax for which they are liable on delivering their account under section 226(2). If the estate is mostly farmland or a trading company, find out early whether an election to pay by instalments is available under section 227(1), because the election is made by written notice to HMRC and can spare the family a forced sale. A claimant is also expected to take reasonable steps to limit the loss. Our page on whether a solicitor must tell you about a mistake explains the duty if your adviser has already admitted an error or gone quiet.

Collect documents before anyone tidies the file: the will, engagement letters, advice emails, attendance notes, records of lifetime gifts with their dates, valuations and any correspondence about claiming the spouse transfer. Sign nothing that releases the adviser or settles a fee dispute until someone independent has read it. Ask for the adviser’s file in writing, and see our guide to claiming compensation for negligent advice for how a claim is put together.

The time limits that decide whether you can still sue

Claims against advisers are usually brought in contract or in tort. The basic period is six years from accrual, under section 5 of the Limitation Act 1980 for contract and section 2 for tort. For negligence actions, section 14A(4)(b) allows three years from the starting date, which is the earliest date on which you had the knowledge required and a right to sue, if that period expires later. Under section 14A(9), knowledge that the acts or omissions amounted to negligence in law is irrelevant, and section 14B(1) sets a fifteen-year limit running from the act or omission alleged to be negligent. Our guide to the limitation period in professional negligence claims sets out the framework.

The harder question is when the clock starts. For tax planning the candidates are the date of the advice, the date a transaction was entered into on it, the date of death when the charge arises under section 4(1), and the date the bill was assessed. We treat the earliest plausible date as the deadline until the file shows otherwise, and because section 14A is aimed at negligence actions, whether it helps a claim pleaded only in contract is checked on each file. Our guide to time-barred compensation in professional negligence claims explains what follows if the date is missed.

How LEXLAW Can Help

We act for claimants in professional negligence claims against solicitors, accountants, tax advisers and financial planners, including claims where inheritance tax planning went wrong. We do not offer free legal advice or legal aid, and we generally take on substantial matters, so a large estate or a family business facing a substantial charge is the kind of case we usually take. Our professional negligence practice handles the litigation, and before a claim is issued the first formal step is usually a letter before claim, which our page on a professional negligence letter before claim explains.

Our solicitors and barristers are dual-qualified, with chambers in Middle Temple next to the Royal Courts of Justice. For a fixed fee we hold an advice conference with a solicitor and a barrister to tell you whether the file supports a claim, which our page on a second opinion on your claim describes, and you can send us the facts through our litigation case assessment form.

FAQs

Can I sue my adviser just because the APR and BPR rules changed?

No claim arises from the change in the law alone. You need advice that fell below what a competent adviser would have given when it was given, a loss caused by that advice, and proceedings brought in time. Advice given after the 30 October 2024 announcement to a farming or business client is where the standard is most likely to matter.

Where is the £2.5 million allowance found in the legislation?

Section 124D(2) IHTA 1984 sets the 100% relief allowance at £2.5 million less relief previously given by transfers in the allowance period, which section 124D(3) defines as the seven years ending with the day of the transfer. Sections 104(1A) and 116(1A) give 100% relief up to that allowance, and the 50% rate applies above it under sections 104(1) and 116(1).

Does a spouse’s unused allowance pass automatically on death?

No. Section 124E(5) increases the survivor’s final allowance amount only where a claim is made under that section, so a missed claim can be a loss. Government guidance extends the transfer to first deaths before 6 April 2026.

Can executors claim on behalf of the estate?

Executors can generally bring a claim that the deceased had against an adviser for the estate’s own loss, such as tax paid that competent advice would have avoided. Beneficiaries may have a separate claim where the adviser owed them a duty, although the same loss cannot be recovered twice.

Can the estate pay the tax by instalments?

Section 227(1) IHTA 1984 allows tax attributable to qualifying property on a death to be paid by ten equal yearly instalments if the person paying elects by written notice to HMRC. Government guidance says the option has been extended to all property that qualifies for APR or BPR and describes the instalments as interest-free.

When is the inheritance tax due after a death?

Under section 226(1) IHTA 1984, tax is due six months after the end of the month in which the death occurred, and under section 226(2) personal representatives pay the tax for which they are liable when they deliver their account. A later dispute with the adviser does not move these dates.

How long do I have to bring a claim against my adviser?

The basic period is six years from accrual under section 2 (tort) and section 5 (contract) of the Limitation Act 1980. For negligence, section 14A(4)(b) can extend it to three years from the date you first had the required knowledge and a right to sue, and section 14B(1) imposes a fifteen-year limit from the act or omission.

What losses can I recover if the claim succeeds?

The core measure is the difference between the tax you face and the tax you would have faced with competent advice, within the scope of the duty the adviser undertook. The cost of putting matters right may also be recoverable. Whether a different step would actually have reduced the tax is the point on which the claim usually turns.

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close