Yes. If your insurer refuses or cuts a claim because your broker arranged the wrong cover, let the policy lapse, or failed to pass on or explain what the insurer needed to know, you may be able to sue the insurance broker for the money the policy should have paid. First you normally have to challenge the insurer, because the broker is liable only for the loss you cannot recover from it.
The people who ask this are usually business owners or homeowners who paid premiums for years and then met a refusal letter at the worst moment, after a fire, a flood, a theft or a claim against them. The surprise is that the insurer’s reasons often lie in what the broker did or knew, and the Insurance Act 2015 gives a policyholder more room to argue than most expect.
Why Insurers Refuse Claims and Where the Broker Fits In
Insurers decline or reduce claims for a handful of reasons. The most common are that something was not disclosed or was misstated when the policy was arranged, that the policy never covered the risk, that the sum insured was too low, and that the policy had lapsed. Each of these can trace back to the person who arranged the insurance. Our guide on claiming compensation for negligent advice lists insurance brokers among the advisers who can be pursued where the cover arranged did not respond.
A broker is paid to find and place cover that suits you and to explain it. Our page on negligent insurance brokers gives examples such as “Failure to provide adequate insurance cover for your needs”, “Providing a far too restrictive insurance product” and “Failure to renew a policy once you have advised them to do so”. It also says a broker must “advise on duty to disclose all material facts and explain the consequences of failing to do so”.
Want legal advice on the merits of your case?
Your legal enquiry goes immediately to our PN litigation team in Middle Temple, London. We can’t take on low value cases or give free legal advice – our minimum fee is £1750 +VAT for a conference with a solicitor and barrister. Call us on +442071830529.
The Duty to Give the Insurer a Fair Presentation
For business insurance, section 3 of the Insurance Act 2015 says: “Before a contract of insurance is entered into, the insured must make to the insurer a fair presentation of the risk.” The presentation must disclose “every material circumstance which the insured knows or ought to know”, or, failing that, give the insurer “sufficient information to put a prudent insurer on notice” to ask more. It must also be reasonably clear and accessible, and every material statement of fact must be substantially correct.
In practice the broker usually collects the information and puts it to the insurer. If a material fact never reached the insurer, the policyholder is the one facing the refusal, but the failure may belong to the person who took the instructions. We assess whether a broker fell below the standard of a reasonably competent practitioner in the way we explain in our guide to breach of duty in professional negligence.
Your Broker’s Knowledge Can Count as Your Knowledge
This point is missed by most articles on the subject. Under section 4 of the Act, what you are treated as knowing includes what is known to the individuals “responsible for the insured’s insurance”. Section 4(8)(b) says an individual is responsible if the individual “participates on behalf of the insured” in procuring the insurance, whether as the insured’s employee or agent or as an employee of the insured’s agent. The explanatory notes suggest that can include an individual acting as the insured’s broker.
The effect is that a material fact your broker knew can be treated as a fact you knew, and so as a fact that had to be disclosed. If the broker held the information and did not pass it on, the insurer may argue the breach is yours, and the natural place to look for the loss is the broker, as in any professional negligence claim. The Act also limits how far an agent’s knowledge is attributed, for example where the agent learned it from an unconnected client, so each case turns on its facts.
What the Insurer Can Do if Information Was Missed
A breach of the duty does not always mean a refusal in full. Under section 8, the insurer has a remedy only if it shows that, but for the breach, it would not have entered the contract at all or would have done so only on different terms. Schedule 1 then sets the remedies. If the breach was deliberate or reckless, paragraph 2 lets the insurer avoid the contract, refuse all claims and keep the premiums, and section 8(6) puts the burden on the insurer to show that.
If the breach was neither deliberate nor reckless, the position under Schedule 1 is milder. Where the insurer would not have contracted on any terms, it may avoid the contract and refuse all claims but must return the premiums (paragraph 4). Where it would have contracted on other terms, the contract is treated as made on those terms (paragraph 5). Where it would have charged a higher premium, it may “reduce proportionately the amount to be paid on a claim” (paragraph 6). Check which of these the insurer relies on, because a proportionate payment is a very different loss from a total refusal.
Home or Personal Policy? Different Rules for Consumers
The fair presentation duty applies to business insurance. A consumer buying cover for a home, car or other personal use is covered by the Consumer Insurance (Disclosure and Representations) Act 2012. Under section 2(2), “It is the duty of the consumer to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation to the insurer.”
The insurer has a remedy only where it shows that, without the misrepresentation, it would not have entered the contract or would have done so on different terms, and a careless misrepresentation is one that is not deliberate or reckless (sections 4 and 5). If a broker filled in the answers for you and got them wrong, our professional negligence practice can review whether the error was yours or theirs.
Cover Too Narrow, Sum Insured Too Low or Policy Not Renewed
Not every broker claim involves disclosure. A policy may exclude the very event that happened, a sum insured may be set far below the real cost of rebuilding or replacing, or renewal may have been missed after you asked for it. If you relied on the broker to match the policy to your needs, the question is what a competent broker would have recommended and whether that cover would have paid. Our page on financial negligence claims covers claims against brokers and other financial professionals.
Some businesses also hold tax investigation or professional fees cover to help pay for an HMRC enquiry. If that cover is refused, our guide to HMRC compliance checks explains what an enquiry involves, our HMRC tax litigation practice acts in those disputes, and a second opinion on an HMRC dispute can help you decide whether to proceed while the insurance question is argued.
Challenge the Insurer First, Then Look at the Broker
Ask the insurer to put its reasons in writing and to say which policy term or which missing fact it relies on. Use its complaints procedure, keep every reply, and write to your broker asking what it told the insurer and when. A claimant must take reasonable steps to reduce the loss, and our guide to how compensation is calculated explains that duty, together with interest on the principal sum.
If the refusal stands, the loss can be large and sudden. Where unpaid creditors then start to press, a statutory demand is a formal demand for a debt that can lead to insolvency proceedings, and our page on setting aside a statutory demand explains the options. Do not wait for the insurer’s final answer before taking advice if limitation is near.
What Can You Recover From the Broker?
The aim is to put you where you would have been if the broker had done the job properly. If proper advice would have produced a policy that paid, the loss is usually what that policy would have paid, less anything you recover from the insurer. If a competent broker would have found cover that did not exist, or that you could not have afforded, the claim is harder. Our article on recoverable damages in professional negligence claims explains how the scope of the broker’s duty limits what a court will award.
Check the broker’s terms of business before you start, because some contain a cap on liability or a short deadline for claims. Our article on a limitation of liability clause explains when a court applies such a term and when it does not.
Broker, Insurer or Insolvent Adviser? Sorting Out the Confusion
Searches about a refused insurance claim often bring up two different problems. A dispute with the insurer about whether the policy responds is one claim, and a claim against the broker for how the policy was arranged is another, and you may have both. A third situation arises where the person who gave you the negligent advice has gone insolvent: our article on an insolvent professional and a claim against their insurer explains when you can go directly to that adviser’s own insurer.
If the same transaction also involved an accountant or financial adviser, they may share responsibility, and our page on negligent accountants and financial advisers covers that side.
Time Limits for Suing an Insurance Broker
Section 2 of the Limitation Act 1980 says: “An action founded on tort shall not be brought after the expiration of six years from the date on which the cause of action accrued.” Section 14A can give three years from the “starting date”, the earliest date you had both the knowledge needed and a right to sue, if that ends later. Section 14B sets a longstop of “fifteen years from the date” of the act or omission. Time in a broker claim can start earlier than the refusal letter, for example when the policy was placed or allowed to lapse.
The Pre-Action Protocol for Professional Negligence says at paragraph 4.1 that it “does not alter the statutory time limits for commencing court proceedings”. Our pages on limitation in professional negligence cases, time-barred compensation, limitation periods generally and how to start a professional negligence claim explain the steps in order.
What to Gather Before You Ask for Advice
Collect the policy schedule and wording, the proposal form or statement of fact, every email or note between you and the broker before the policy was placed, the renewal documents, the insurer’s refusal letter and any complaint replies. Write down what you told the broker and what you were told about the cover. Our professional negligence FAQs answer common questions about what a claim needs.
How We Can Help
We act for businesses, directors and individuals with substantial claims against insurance brokers, solicitors, accountants, tax advisers, surveyors and financial advisers. We read the policy, the broker’s file and the insurer’s refusal, tell you plainly whether the loss can be recovered from the insurer or from the broker, and advise on a claim where it is worth bringing. We do not offer free legal advice or legal aid, and we generally take on substantial matters only. If you are unsure who is at fault, we also offer a second opinion on a professional negligence claim.
We are dual qualified solicitors and barristers with chambers at 4 Middle Temple Lane, next to the Royal Courts of Justice. We offer a fixed fee advice conference with both a solicitor and a barrister, where we review your documents and advise on the next step. To begin, complete our professional negligence case assessment form.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sue my insurance broker if my claim was refused?
Yes, if the broker fell below the standard of a reasonably competent broker and that failure caused a loss the insurer will not cover. Typical examples are cover that did not fit your needs, information not passed to the insurer, or a renewal that was missed. You normally challenge the insurer first, because the broker answers only for the loss you cannot recover from it.
Does the insurer have to pay anything if I missed disclosing something?
Sometimes. For business insurance, Schedule 1 to the Insurance Act 2015 lets the insurer refuse all claims only where the breach was deliberate or reckless (paragraph 2), or where it would not have contracted on any terms (paragraph 4). Otherwise the contract may be treated as made on different terms (paragraph 5) or the claim reduced proportionately (paragraph 6), and section 8(6) puts the burden of proving a deliberate or reckless breach on the insurer.
Does my broker’s knowledge count as my knowledge for the insurance?
It can. Section 4 of the Insurance Act 2015 treats an insured as knowing what is known to the individuals responsible for the insured’s insurance, and section 4(8)(b) says an individual is responsible if they participate on behalf of the insured in procuring the insurance, including as the insured’s agent. There are limits, so the facts of each case matter.
How long do I have to sue an insurance broker?
Section 2 of the Limitation Act 1980 gives six years from the date the cause of action accrued. Section 14A can give three years from the date you had the knowledge needed to sue, if that ends later, and section 14B sets a 15 year longstop from the act or omission. Only issuing a claim form stops the clock, and writing a letter of claim does not.
This article is general information, not legal advice.
